Who could ever tell that someone had gone round twice, or that a family was represented at three different distribution points? If the beneficiaries tell us clearly, as they did, time and again in Goma, that what they needed was cash, why did aid agencies persist in giving them goods? Cost-recovery in the health sector: Nevertheless, it was abundantly clear that, after the eruption, the one thing the people of Goma needed was money. There was overwhelming evidence that, within a day or two, the only value of another plastic sheet or another cooking-pot was in its sale. This became a problem in itself, as agencies had become used to the convenience of doing distributions inside a compound, and were reluctant to stop supporting people in the schools.
Home Explore Case study of a Volcanic eruption: While there may be genuine and well-founded fears around cash aid, there is only one real conclusion to be drawn: Could the clue be in the agency stickers plastering every aid vehicle in Goma, and the agency logos everywhere? Exactly the same problems of identification and duplication would have occurred. User-managed public health promotion in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam.
Case study of a Volcanic eruption : Mt. Nyiragongo
Lessons in Post-Disaster Assistance from Goma, unpublished case study, The international politics of aid in the occupied Palestinian territory. The fear of giving money is almost pathological among aid agencies, even though, or maybe because, it would be simpler and cheaper to give than any other form of help.
Why, then, did agencies continue to supply these items, even when it was obvious that they had become currency, and a debased one at that, as the continuing supply of new sheets and pots reduced their sale value to virtually zero and impoverished the people who normally sold them?
What they needed was not sttudy but cash.
Food security in the occupied Palestinian territory. Exactly nyiagongo same problems of identification and duplication would have occurred. It suffered an economic downturn for the nyiragpngo years as the tourist trade collapsed with few visitors. Many cross the border intonearby Rwanda and become refugees therewith little food, water or clothes. Humanitarian response in the occupied Palestinian territory: Perhaps goods should have been given only to women, as at one point UNICEF had decided to do, or only to children, or only through churches.
Family kits, providing household items, were important and greatly needed, but everything in the kit could be bought in Goma.
The economic activity which the programme revived, based on carpenters and builders, sent a buzz through the whole town and demonstrated clearly what mounf difference the reintroduction of wages made to the economy.
Mental health needs in Palestine. Evacuation is nearly impossible as moutn Constructive margin in LEDCvolcanic ash prevents jets from taking off andthe runway is covered in a lava flow.
The town is a busy commercial centre, a hive of economic activity and the main point of entry for goods from the outside world for much of eastern Congo. Money does not even have to be given free though the food, pots and sheets were.
There is abundant evidence from around the globe that post-disaster economies revive quickly if everyone has a little money to spend. We’ll assume you’re ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.
The people of Goma were clearly right: Create your own flipbook. New aid workers are warned by older and wiser colleagues never to give cash to beneficiaries. But perhaps the aid community could be radical and say that people, especially adults, have a right to misuse their cash.
In particular, a huge school rebuilding programme generated vklcano, employment and an explosion of small workshops making desks and chairs. Goma had been a tourist resort with hotels overlooking the lake.
Homes, schools, churches and businesses were ruined. View in Fullscreen Report. Home Explore Case study of a Volcanic eruption: The communications revolution in the Palestinian territories. For this major and crucial need, only cash would do.
Volcanoes – Revision 3 – KS3 Geography – BBC Bitesize
If the beneficiaries tell us clearly, as they did, time and again in Goma, that what they needed was cash, why did aid agencies persist in giving them goods? Yet the aid community in Goma continued to hold to some moral high ground about giving cash.
It was no secret that they were going to sell the goods, and that the ensuing flood of cheap aluminium pots or plastic sheets would debase the local market and make things worse for small traders. User-managed public health promotion in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam.
The aid response, both by the UN and NGOs, focused on this loss of shelter, and defined entitlement to assistance according to its loss. It is arguable that losses would be no less than they are in massive nyjragongo distributions.
It also caused methane gas http: